Michael Gerson’s column Immigration and Political Suicide is so far off the mark, that it should probably be ignored. However, there are some points that beg for clarification. Gerson contends that Hispanics, made to feel unwelcome in the Republican party, voted overwhelmingly for Obama. This faulty logic cannot go unanswered.
It was Republican presidential candidate John McCain, after all, who was the leading voice on what was euphemistically called Comprehensive Immigration Reform, but was actually nothing more than an amnesty plan for millions of illegals and a welcome mat for millions more. He pandered to the racist La Raza, a group that partners with the radical MEChA, whose slogan is: “Por la Raza todo. Fuera de La Raza nada,” which translates to “For the race, everything. Outside of the race, nothing.” Their founding manifesto rejects the very notion of respect for U.S. borders — “We do not recognize capricious frontiers on the bronze continent [the United States]” — and vow to repel the “brutal ‘gringo’ invasion of our territories.”
Add to the mix McCain’s campaign Hispanic Outreach Director, Juan Hernandez who declared “we are not countries, merely regions.”
In making his fallacious case Gerson contends “non-college-educated whites are declining as a portion of the electorate,” implying that only undereducated rednecks oppose illegal immigration.
Is Gerson aware of the proliferation of Reconquista studies programs being taught in the Tucson Unified School District? Even the most educated Arizonans find them intolerable.
He asserts “Catholics and evangelicals, who have been central to the Republican coalition, cannot ultimately accept a message of resentment against foreigners. Their faith will not allow it.”
He attempts to bolster that argument with this absurdity: “In considering illegal immigration, many talk appropriately about the rule of law. But there is also the imago dei — the shared image of God — that does not permit individual worth and dignity to be sorted by national origin.”
Mr. Gerson: it is not “resentment against foreigners,” that drives this issue. America was founded by newcomers and immigrants to this country who become proud, assimilated, Americans, enriching the nation. You are intentionally confusing legal immigration with unlawful entry of illegals who care not a whit for our national borders or laws and who compound their initial acts with more criminality once they have entered the United States.
Gerson, who studied theology and worked within prison ministries, also complains that making it illegal for priests, ministers and volunteers to “assist” illegal immigrants criminalizes “a religious duty.”
He is currently a senior research fellow in the misguided Center on Faith & International Affairs at the Institute for Global Engagement.
This might help you understand the problem, Mr. Gerson.